Initial Response to SAC’s Paper ‘Brahma-gayatri mantra in ISKCON’

Abstract

In Kṛṣṇa’s Vedic civilization, upanayana — the investiture with the sacred thread and brahma-gāyatrī — is exclusively conferred upon qualified men, with women and śūdras being excluded. In the early days, Śrīla Prabhupāda, to pacify a few irate female disciples who had revolted because of not getting second initiation, started the practice of granting brahma-gāyatrī to his female disciples but without the sacred thread, implying they were not genuine brāhmaṇas. As time passed and senior devotees gained deeper knowledge of Kṛṣṇa’s Vedic culture they realized what had happened. Some who had by now become initiating gurus reverted to Kṛṣṇa’s original standard and ceased giving their female disciples brahma-gāyatrī at the time of second initiation and became more stringent with male disciples, reserving it only for those displaying brahminical tendencies. This shift challenged those advocating for Female Diksa Gurus in ISKCON and other feminist initiatives. Consequently, the GBC approached SAC for guidance on this matter and SAC provided āpasiddhāntik and heterodox arguments to sanction brahma-gāyatrī for women and unqualified men.

This essay serves as an initial response to SAC’s paper. Here, we highlight that SAC concocted its method of textual interpretation (that yields predetermined results) while disregarding Kṛṣṇa’s original method — Mīmāṁsā. We emphasize the importance of understanding the guru’s “mano- ‘bhīṣṭaṁ” (mind’s desire) when interpreting his actions, which are ultimately rooted in śāstra. SAC misunderstands our dīkṣā process. Since brahma-gāyatrī is part of our dīkṣā protocol we must first understand how our system of dīkṣā works.Thus we analyze the initiation framework in our sampradāya — which contains elements of Bhāgavata, Pañcarātrika, and Vaidika traditions. Next we show that SAC ignored the fundamental question on which everything hinges — Why did Śrīla Bhaktisiddhānta Sarasvatī Ṭhākura introduce upanayana? And, show that after answering this question SAC’s whole argument collapses. We also discuss the GBC’s flawed resolutions which they based on SAC’s non-peer reviewed paper.

Please read the document here – pdf.

Share:

Follow us

Padmanayana Krsna Dasa

View Comments

Recent Posts

250X Cadmium?

Not Humanly Possible 250XNot-PDownload 250X-NOT-PTextBDownload

7 hours ago

GBC and ISKCON India at an Impasse Over Who Should Judge the Female Diksa-Guru Debate, Says IISB’s Krishna Kirti Das

Twelve days before the GBC's moratorium on all ISKCON initiations takes effect, the convenor of…

1 day ago

Female in Spirit, Male in Body: A Guide to Damodara Dasa’s Blog Archive Against Female Diksa-Gurus

Thirteen of the twenty gurus in the Bhagavad-gita's disciplic succession are female in their eternal…

1 day ago

LA Mayor-Elect Nithya Raman Marks Diwali at City Hall With Krishna’s Victory Over Narakasura

At her last Diwali presentation as a council member and her first as mayor-elect, the…

1 day ago

Can Anyone Be a Diksa-Guru? IISB Opens a Three-Part Video Series on Rohini-tanaya Dasa’s Paper

The ISKCON India Scholars Board has opened a three-part video series on Rohini-tanaya Dasa’s paper…

7 days ago

Can a Departed Guru Still Initiate? Basu Ghosh Das Answers the Ritvik Case Point by Point

Recorded in Vrindavan during Kartik, a new ISKCON India Scholars Board video puts the ritvik…

7 days ago