Below are comments I sent in to Dandavats.com shortly after they posted the GBC announcement of authorizing women diksa gurus within ISKCON. That was in mid October. The article they posted was prominently displayed on their website for at least two months, but is no longer there. Whatever the reason is for that Dandavats only allowed three supportive comments on that article. With such a controversial decision it’s very likely several more comments were sent in. From past experience I knew Dandavats doesn’t accompany views that conflict with their authoritative position. Nonetheless I sent these comments in, urging the GBC to find another solution which won’t create further and deeper divisions within the movement. As expected, these comments were not posted:

Since there is evidence in sastra such as Narada Pancaratra, as well as statements from Srila Prabhupada which restrict women from being diksa gurus, a win win solution for the GBC would have been to promote women as primary gurus in the siksa role. Historically this was a common practice, such as Narottama das Thakur took diksa from Lokanath Goswami, but his primary guru was Jiva Goswami as his siksa guru. The diksa guru role has been overemphasized within ISKCON and it is a philosophical misunderstanding. To keep more ISKCON devotees on board and in agreement with policies generated by the GBC it is wise to come up with solutions which are bonafide as well as acceptable to most at least. Making conditional arrangements to implement something objectionable to a section of the society is not ideal.

Share:

Follow us

sankirta

Recent Posts

Taking Care of Krishna’s Cows Course Invitation

ISKCON GLOBAL MINISTRY OF COW PROTECTION AND AGRICULTURE (IMCPA) FEED THE EARTHEDUCATION PROJECT FEED THE…

10 hours ago

ISKCON’s First Stone Temple Construction Update – April 2025

ISKCON's First stone temple | Construction masterpiece to last 1000s of years | Traditional temple…

11 hours ago

Shamanism ends in Vaishnavism: A Vaishnava Perspective on Ayahuasca

Shamanism ends in Vaishnavism: A Vaishnava Perspective on Ayahuasca The subject of this article—ayahuasca—may not…

2 weeks ago

Authorized Dates for Observing the Jagannatha Rathayatra: Presentations and Research Findings by the ISKCON India Scholars Board (IISB)

The ISKCON India Scholars Board (IISB) recently presented a series of research findings and discussions…

3 weeks ago

Meeting between ISKCON India Scholars Board and the Sri Jagannath Temple management authorities

Meeting between ISKCON India Scholars Board Representatives and the Sri Jagannath Temple Management Authorities By…

4 weeks ago

Using Cadmium to Deceive

Don’t Accept Cadmium Stories from a Layman When our parents taught us NOT to accept…

1 month ago