“Some philosophers say that because of the first living entity’s sin, all the other living entities are imprisoned in the material world. Later, punishing Himself for their sins, God delivers the living entities.”
“Deliberating on the virtues and faults of this world, some moralistic monotheists concluded that the material world is not a place of pure happiness. Indeed, the sufferings outweigh the pleasures. They claim that the material world is a prison to punish the living entities. If there is punishment, then there must be a crime. If there were no crime, then why would there be any punishment? What crime did the living entities commit? Unable to properly answer this question, some men of small intelligence gave birth to a very wild idea. God created the first man and placed him in a pleasant garden with his wife. Then God forbade the man to taste the fruit of the tree of knowledge. Following the evil counsel of a wicked being [a snake], the first man and woman tasted the fruit of the tree of knowledge, thus disobeying God’s command. In this way, they fell from that garden into the material world filled with suffering. Because of their offense, all other living entities are offenders from the moment of their birth. Not seeing any other way to remove this offense, God Himself took birth in a humanlike form, took on His own shoulders the sins of His followers, and then died [was crucified]. All who follow Him easily attain liberation, and all who do not follow Him fall into an eternal Hell. In this way, God assumes a humanlike form, punishes Himself, and thus liberates the living entities. An intelligent person cannot make sense of any of this!”
Bhaktivinoda Thakur in his book, Tattva-viveka.
New Release on Guru Pūrṇimā On this auspicious Guru Pūrṇimā, we’re pleased to release our…
Support this channel: https://donate.bvksmedia.net/ Recorded on April 22, 2025 in Atlanta, GA, USA For thousands…
Support this channel: https://donate.bvksmedia.net/ Recorded on June 30, 2025 in Manchester, UK. For thousands of…
Join us today for a critical examination in light of shastra and previous acharyas the…
Join us for an in-depth discussion from our June 12, 2025, meeting exploring the controversial…